Gender Selection Myths Debunked: What Really Works and What Doesn't
📢 Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products backed by research.
When I started researching how to conceive a boy, I encountered a lot of advice. Some of it was based on legitimate scientific research. Some of it was... questionable at best. And some of it was flat-out nonsense passed down through generations as "old wives' tales."
In this article, I'm going to separate fact from fiction. I'll tell you which methods have at least some scientific backing, which ones are harmless but probably useless, and which ones you should ignore completely. Consider this your BS detector for gender selection advice.
Let's debunk some myths.
Myths That Are Completely False (Don't Waste Your Time)
❌ Myth #1: The Chinese Gender Prediction Chart Works
The Claim: An ancient Chinese chart can predict your baby's gender based on the mother's age and the month of conception.
The Reality: This chart has been tested in scientific studies, and it performs no better than a coin flip—about 50% accurate. There's zero biological mechanism by which the mother's age and conception month would influence which sperm fertilizes the egg.
Verdict: Complete myth. Fun for entertainment, but scientifically worthless.
❌ Myth #2: Sleeping on Your Left Side Determines Gender
The Claim: Sleeping position during conception (or during pregnancy) influences the baby's gender.
The Reality: Gender is determined at the moment of fertilization by which sperm (X or Y) reaches the egg first. Your sleeping position has absolutely no effect on sperm selection or the fertilization process.
Verdict: Complete myth. Sleep however you're comfortable.
❌ Myth #3: Eating Sweets Will Give You a Girl (Or Salty Foods for a Boy)
The Claim: Eating sweet foods makes you more likely to conceive a girl, while salty foods increase the odds of a boy.
The Reality: While there is some evidence that mineral intake (potassium and sodium) may play a role, it's not about "sweet vs. salty." The research points to specific minerals and their effect on cervical mucus and egg receptivity, not flavor preferences.
Verdict: Mostly myth. The alkaline diet theory has more nuance than this oversimplification.
❌ Myth #4: The Ring Test (Pendulum Over the Belly)
The Claim: Dangling a ring on a string over a pregnant woman's belly can reveal the baby's gender based on how it swings.
The Reality: This is pure superstition. The ring's movement is caused by tiny, involuntary hand movements (ideomotor effect), not any mystical connection to the baby's gender.
Verdict: Complete myth. Same accuracy as flipping a coin.
Methods With SOME Scientific Basis (Worth Considering)
⚠️ The Shettles Method (Timing Intercourse)
The Claim: Having intercourse as close to ovulation as possible increases the chances of conceiving a boy because Y-sperm are faster but less hardy.
The Reality: This method is based on Dr. Shettles' observations of sperm behavior. Some studies support the timing theory, while others have found no correlation. The success rate is debated, but many couples report success with this approach.
My Take: I used this method for both of my sons. The logic makes sense, and it's easy to implement. Even if the science isn't ironclad, it doesn't hurt to try.
⚠️ Alkaline Diet / Mineral Intake
The Claim: Eating foods high in potassium and sodium (and lower in calcium and magnesium) can shift your body's pH and favor male conception.
The Reality: There is some research supporting this, particularly a Dutch study that found an 80% success rate for women who strictly followed a high-potassium, low-calcium diet. However, the evidence is limited and not consistently replicated.
My Take: I didn't follow a strict diet, but I did focus on alkaline-forming foods and stayed hydrated with alkaline water. The dietary changes are generally healthy, so there's little downside.
⚠️ Deep Penetration / Sexual Positioning
The Claim: Sexual positions that allow for deeper penetration deposit sperm closer to the cervix, giving faster Y-sperm an advantage.
The Reality: The vagina has an acidic pH that's more hostile to Y-sperm. The cervical mucus is more alkaline. In theory, deeper penetration could reduce Y-sperm's exposure to acidic conditions. The evidence is anecdotal, but the logic is sound.
My Take: This was part of our strategy. It's easy to implement and doesn't require supplements or tracking, so why not?
⚠️ Male Fertility Supplements
The Claim: Supplements like zinc, vitamin C, and antioxidants can improve sperm health and potentially favor Y-sperm survival.
The Reality: There's strong evidence that certain vitamins and minerals improve overall sperm health (motility, morphology, DNA integrity). Whether they specifically favor Y-sperm is less clear, but healthier sperm in general increases conception odds.
My Take: I took a male fertility supplement (FertilAid) for 3 months before trying to conceive. I believe it helped strengthen my sperm overall.
Controversial or Questionable Methods
🤔 The Babydust Method
What It Is: A newer approach developed by Kathryn Taylor that uses ion concentration in cervical mucus to predict the best days for conceiving a boy or girl.
The Debate: The Babydust Method claims a higher success rate than Shettles, but it's based on limited research and hasn't been independently replicated. Some couples swear by it; others see no difference from Shettles.
My Take: I didn't use this method personally. It's worth researching if you're interested, but I found the Shettles Method simpler and more established.
🤔 Douching with Baking Soda
What It Is: Using a baking soda solution to raise vaginal pH and create a more alkaline environment for Y-sperm.
The Debate: While the theory makes sense (alkaline = better for Y-sperm), douching can disrupt the vaginal microbiome and increase the risk of infections. Most doctors don't recommend it.
My Take: I did not do this. The risks outweigh the potential benefits. Focus on diet and timing instead.
🤔 High Calorie Intake
What It Is: Some research suggests women who consume more calories (especially at breakfast) are more likely to conceive boys.
The Debate: One UK study found a correlation, but it's unclear if it's causation or just coincidence. The mechanism isn't well understood.
My Take: This is an easy one to try—just eat a good breakfast. No harm in it, even if the effect is small or nonexistent.
What I Actually Did (And What Worked for Me)
When I look back at everything I tried, here's what I actually stuck with and what I believe made a difference:
✅ Methods I Used
- Timing intercourse on ovulation day (Shettles Method)
- Male fertility supplements (zinc, vitamin C, L-carnitine)
- Strategic sexual positions (deep penetration)
- Focus on female arousal and climax
- Alkaline-forming foods (loosely followed)
❌ Methods I Skipped
- Chinese gender chart
- Baking soda douching
- Strict diet restrictions
- Any "old wives' tale" methods (moon phases, sleeping positions, etc.)
The result? Two healthy boys. Did every method contribute? Probably not. But I focused on the approaches that had some scientific rationale and avoided anything that was purely superstition or potentially harmful.
Final Thoughts: Be Smart, Be Realistic
Here's my advice: stick to methods that have at least some scientific plausibility, and ignore the rest. Don't waste your time on superstitions or unproven theories that sound too good to be true.
The Shettles Method, male fertility supplements, and dietary awareness are all reasonable approaches backed by some degree of research or logical reasoning. The Chinese gender chart, sleeping positions, and pendulum tests? Not so much.
And remember: nothing is guaranteed. Even the best methods only shift the odds slightly. If you get pregnant with a healthy baby—boy or girl—you've already won.
Good luck, and approach this journey with both hope and realism.
